Xray Posts
English
Regulatory Updates

NZ Commerce Commission chair urges justified resilience spending as draft principles draw feedback

New Zealand Commerce Commission Chair Dr John Small said infrastructure resilience investment must balance reduced disruption with costs consumers are willing to bear. In published speech highlights, he said the regulator had received around 40 submissions on draft resilience principles, with discussion focused on proportionality and organisations’ approaches to resilience.

New Zealand Commerce Commission Chair Dr John Small said regulated infrastructure providers should plan early for resilience investment and demonstrate its value to consumers, as the regulator considers feedback on draft resilience principles.

In written highlights published on November 11, 2026, from an address to the Lifeline Utilities Forum in Hamilton, Small said the Commission had received around 40 submissions on the draft principles and held an open workshop the previous month. Much of the discussion had focused on the proportionality of investment and the maturity of organisations’ approaches to resilience. The remarks did not announce final principles or a new spending approval.

Small said the Commission’s role in assessing capital expenditure proposals in some regulated sectors was to allow prudent investment while preventing excessive or unsupported spending. Approving expenditure effectively allows companies to recover those costs from consumers, making it necessary to establish that investment is justified.

He urged firms to test their assumptions and engage with customers about what they value and are willing to pay for. Very high reliability could be worth the cost in some circumstances, he said, while consumers might reasonably prefer lower reliability where additional resilience would be extremely expensive.

Small cited analysis covering the 15 years from 2010 that put disaster response and insurance payouts across the public and private sectors at an average of around $4.2 billion annually. He said investment ahead of disasters could make recovery faster, cheaper and less disruptive, but the difficult questions were how much to spend, where and on what.

He described resilience as a form of insurance, while noting that infrastructure investment differs from traditional insurance because it usually involves physical works and delivers shared benefits. Those shared benefits mean markets tend to under-provide resilience, he said.

Small also stressed that resilience extends beyond hard infrastructure to green infrastructure, operational capabilities and community relationships. Because power, communications, water and transport networks depend on one another, he called for regulated organisations to participate actively in regional lifeline groups and other collaborative networks before disruptions occur.